PerformYard vs 15Five

Discover why HR leaders choose PerformYard instead of 15Five for their performance management strategies.

We checked out a few other systems, but ultimately decided PerformYard was the best fit because of cost, ease of use, customer service, customization, and features. We also checked references and spoke with PerformYard clients who could attest to their experience, which PerformYard was happy to provide!
– Emily P. G2 Review
My number one favorite thing about PerformYard is the consistent reminder emails about outstanding reviews. On other platforms, if a timeline runs out and the manager didn't do the review, it still closes the review without telling anyone. PerformYard will stay open and outstanding so I can make sure managers are actually doing their reviews.
– Current PerformYard Customer
PerformYard was easier to use, had more functionality, and more customization [compared to other platforms]. We vastly preferred PerformYard and it even had a better price.
– Randy M. TrustRadius Review

PerformYard

PerformYard is designed for flexibility, customization, and a streamlined employee experience for any review process.

15Five

15Five was originally designed more for 1:1 meetings, but they have since expanded their product offering.  

Compare

PerformYard vs 15Five Comparison

Compare PerformYard vs 15Five and discover which performance management software is right for you.

PerformYard
15Five
Pricing
Starts at $5
Starts at $10
Ease of Setup (G2)
9.0
8.8
Quality of Support (G2)
9.7
9.2
Product Direction (G2)
9.0
8.7
Ease of Use (G2)
9.3
9.1
Business Partner Rating (G2)
9.7
9.2
Performance Management for Accounting Firms

What Sets PerformYard Apart

PerformYard is Flexible

Tailored Performance Management Solutions

What PerformYard Does

PerformYard enables organizations to design a unique performance management process that aligns with their specific company culture.

The platform supports organizations of all sizes and industries, and it does not enforce a rigid process but instead streamlines the one you choose to implement.

What 15Five Does

15Five can outperform manual tools like spreadsheets for managing performance and engagement, yet some users report difficulty setting up custom questions. This issue affects both engagement surveys and performance reviews, making customization less straightforward than expected.

PerformYard is Easy

Simplified Employee Reviews

What PerformYard Does

PerformYard allows you to schedule and send review forms with just a few clicks, while also enabling automated notifications for sign-offs and hand-offs.

All performance data is captured within a single platform that offers detailed reporting.

What 15Five Does

While 15Five offers a basic platform for completing reviews, some reviewers struggle with simple actions such as pushing tasks to the next week, editing review entries, or generating accurate reports. These limitations can reduce overall efficiency.

PerformYard is Human

Unlimited Expert Support

What PerformYard Does

PerformYard includes account setup, live training sessions, a dedicated success manager, and phone support in every plan.

Employee training sessions can be customized for your organization, and support is extended to employees to ensure buy-in during implementation.

What 15Five Does

15Five provides customer support documentation, but some users note that assistance often comes in the form of pre-recorded webinars. They feel this approach is not personalized and does not adequately address specific user issues.

User Reviews

Over 2,500 HR Pros Trust PerformYard to Simplify Performance Management

G2 Crowd
4.8 out of 5 stars
Capterra
4.8 out of 5 stars
Software Advice
4.8 out of 5 stars
Trust Radius
4.5 out of 5 stars
Testimonial Text
Testimonial Author
Authors Industry
PerformYard makes performance management user-friendly, purposeful, and FUN!
Hannah W.
E-Learning
Great system and even better implementation.
Lucy N.
Telecommunications
PerformYard helps me ensure I’m getting completed forms from every employee.
Mike B.
Environmental Serv.
Easy to work with and slick to look at!
Linda K.
IT Services
The setup of forms and templates was much easier than anticipated.
Kathy B.
Financial Services
PerformYard makes performance management user-friendly, purposeful, and FUN!
Hannah W.
E-Learning
Great system and even better implementation.
Lucy N.
Telecommunications
PerformYard helps me ensure I’m getting completed forms from every employee.
Mike B.
Environmental Serv.
Easy to work with and slick to look at!
Linda K.
IT Services
The setup of forms and templates was much easier than anticipated.
Kathy B.
Financial Services
Awesome way to track goals!
Jan K.
Engineering
The product itself is great, but it is the customer service that throws it over the top for me.
Devinne C.
Software
Most user-friendly performance review site ever!
Melissa P.
Architecture
Simple interface and easy to use.
Carl C.
IT Consulting
Very user friendly and easy to navigate.
Amy S.
Software
HR's best friend.
Cassie F.
Nonprofit
Goodbye Excel, Hello PerformYard!
Scott L.
Library Network
PerformYard is easy to use and easy to customize.
Jessica A.
Security
Easy to use and lots of hands-on help when we wanted.
Crystal W.
Telecommunications
Customer success is excellent to work with.
Angie K.
Home Furnishings
Quite intuitive and easy to follow.
Abhinav S.
Software
We reviewed 12+ systems and PerformYard was the best.
Diane P.
Consulting Services
We integrated goals, performance ratings, and more into one system.
Valerie W.
Architecture
Saved us so much time.
Carla M.
Packaging Solutions
Customer service has been outstanding.
Kelly M.
Media
Makes employee reviews a breeze.
Rocky P.
Engineering
The onboarding and customer service is exceptional.
Dawn G.
Marketing
Smart, lean and seamless solution.
Jason J.
IT Consulting
I love the dashboard that shows me everything I need to know at a quick glance.
Joanne T.
Healthcare
Flexible, easy and intuitive.
Ashley A.
Consulting
G2: Best Relationship Mid-MarketG2: Momentum Leader Winter 2024G2 Top 100 Highest Satisfaction Products Best Software Awards 2023G2: High Performer Enterprise Winter 2024G2 Leader Winter 2024

A Leader in Customer Satisfaction

PerformYard customers have a 95% likelihood to recommend according to G2.

200k+
People benefitting from PerformYard
1800+
Organizations using PerformYard
1000+
Public Reviews
9.7/10
Customer Relationship Score
9.7/10
Quality of Support
95%
Likelihood to Recommend

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the difference between PerformYard and 15Five?

PerformYard focuses on customizable performance management solutions, offering flexible review cycles, goals, and feedback structures. In contrast, 15Five emphasizes continuous feedback and employee engagement tools. PerformYard’s adaptability to diverse company needs makes it a more comprehensive choice for performance management, while 15Five leans toward engagement and development.

How do I know which performance management software is right for me?

Choose PerformYard if you prioritize a performance management system that adapts to your unique processes with comprehensive reporting tools. It’s designed for companies that want flexibility without added complexity, making it a great fit for performance-focused businesses looking for simplicity and customization.

Can PerformYard meet my current and future needs?

Yes, PerformYard’s scalable design ensures that as your company grows, it will continue to meet your performance management needs. Its flexible features, tailored review cycles, and dynamic reporting adapt to changing business goals, providing lasting value both now and in the future.

What makes PerformYard’s customer support better than 15Five?

PerformYard’s customer support is highly personalized, offering dedicated account managers to guide clients through setup and ongoing use. This tailored approach ensures faster response times and a deeper understanding of each client's needs, giving it an edge over 15Five's more generalized support model.

Will my employees like using PerformYard?

Yes, employees will appreciate PerformYard’s intuitive interface, making the review process simple and transparent. It fosters an environment of clear feedback and continuous improvement, empowering employees to engage more effectively with their performance goals and professional development.

How does PerformYard enhance manager effectiveness?

PerformYard equips managers with powerful tools to streamline performance reviews, track goals, and provide meaningful feedback. Its customizable workflows ensure that managers can focus on employee development without getting bogged down by administrative tasks, ultimately driving better team performance.